Millions Wasted On Unknown Government Ghost Workers
Britain's state has built half a dozen quiet ways of paying people to be elsewhere, and almost no way of counting them. Holyrood, Cardiff Bay, Stormont, and Whitehall each run their own version, and a Scottish reorganisation is about to make the bill far larger.
Seventeen years ago, a post at NHS Highland ceased to exist. The salary and benefits carried on without it, and they are carrying on still. Asked to explain, the health board said it follows the "national redeployment policy." It gave no detail of the role or the pay in all those years.
The case surfaced last month in a Sunday Times investigation, which gathered data from 70 Scottish public bodies. It found 794 people on the public payroll whose fixed roles had gone.
| Sector | Redeployable | Over one year | Over five years | Longest wait | Reported annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NHS | 500 | 163 | 31 | 17 years | £16.8m |
| Councils | 218 | 54 | 8 | 10 years | £5.8m |
| Other bodies | 76 | 38 | 10 | 7 years | £4.9m |
| Total | 794 | 255 | 49 | £27.6m |
The NHS figure covers only 315 of the 500 cases, because salary data for the other 185 was incomplete. It also excludes 32 Scottish Government officials on a "priority movers" list, who cost another £2m to £2.4m a year. Eleven of them earn between £80,172 and £92,533.
The Scottish Government says redeployed staff should be doing appropriate work for their pay scale. Unnamed sources say they typically take on less senior roles or ad hoc duties.
If the sources are right, this means senior salaries attached to junior work, for years at a time, with no published record of what the work is.
Professor Alan Boyter, a former senior NHS human resources director, called anything near 17 years "outrageous and a serious management failure".
Scotland is only one version of a habit which runs through every administration in the United Kingdom: the state cannot bring itself to end a salary, and rarely tells anyone how many it is still paying. All with your money.
A 2007 Promise Ministers Can No Longer Define
The no compulsory redundancy commitment dates from 2007. The April 2025 technical guide tells public bodies to negotiate extensions of it with their unions, and it covers all directly employed staff for the agreed period.
Councils are not bound by it, although many keep their own lists.
- In 2025, Shona Robison said compulsory redundancy would be considered "as a last resort".
- On 2nd September 2026, John Swinney promised to maintain the pledge: "There is no question about that in my mind."
- On 1st October, Murdo Fraser asked Ivan McKee, the Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform, whether compulsory redundancy was the end point for staff with no role left. "Yes, but a very extensive process sits before that," McKee replied. Six days later he told the chamber the policy was "exactly the same as it always has been".
A rule which means never, except at the end of a process nobody has described, works as a ban for as long as no manager wants to be the first to test it.
At the same committee, Fraser asked what these staff cost across the public sector. McKee said he could not put a number on it.
An estimate arrived three weeks later, from a newspaper. Nobody should be surprised: in 2024, Audit Scotland warned the Government lacked good quality data on its own public sector workforce.
The Scottish Government has advertised posts open only to priority movers, with applications from anyone else rejected. Even with the door closed to the rest of Scotland, the list stood at 32 in September. McKee also told the committee: "until now the Scottish Government has not had a voluntary scheme".
Staff with no post had neither a push out of the door nor a paid way through it.
In August 2023, Edinburgh's redeployment report listed 14 people, five of whom had been waiting six years or more. The bill was put at over £700,000.
A Green amendment praised the arrangement for "preserving talent and expertise", a generous description of seven years spent waiting for a vacancy in an organisation of 14,000.
The city still had nine people on its list at £437,000 a year this autumn.
In Clackmannanshire, a 2023 council report recorded unions "firmly opposed to any change to the indefinite redeployment period". A survey for Dumfries and Galloway Council last year found 18 of 31 councils capped redeployment at 12 weeks, and seven imposed no limit at all.
Clackmannanshire then ran the experiment for everyone else. From January 2024 it replaced the indefinite period with a six-month limit.
| Clackmannanshire | Redeployed | Left on voluntary terms | Still waiting |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023, no limit | 1 | 3 | 4 |
| Jan-Nov 2024 | 6 | 10 | 1 |
Sixteen cases were settled in 11 months, against four in the whole of 2023. The one person left waiting was doing temporary duties inside the six months.
NHS Scotland's policy grants access to redeployment for three months in the first instance. Scotland's land records agency envisages three months at most.
Seventeen years is 68 times three months.
The NHS Highland salary is unpublished, but a rough sum is unkind enough. The costed NHS cases average about £53,000 a year in employment costs. A Treasury consultation described the NHS redundancy scheme as capped at 24 months' pay, or about £107,000 at most on those figures.
Seventeen years at the same rate comes to about £900,000.
Elsewhere, an employee who unreasonably refuses suitable work loses the right to a redundancy payment. Without dismissal at the end of the road, the penalty has nothing to bite on. Those who turn down redeployment can stay on full salary with no fixed role.
Nobody Knows In Whitehall
Whitehall keeps compulsory redundancy terms on its books, and its numbers are small. In May and June 2025, written questions, many of them from John Cooper, the Conservative MP for Dumfries and Galloway, asked department after department how many civil servants had no assigned post.
| Department | Answer |
|---|---|
| Transport | 61 on its priority list, and none "without assigned posts" |
| Energy Security | 34 on its redeployment list |
| Housing | 27 from about 3,900 staff |
| Work and Pensions | 11 without assigned posts |
| Health | Five, on temporary assignments |
Transport's reply is a small masterpiece: 61 people on a list for those needing posts, and nobody needing a post.
The Foreign Office said the Civil Service does not formally use such terms, and then described its own Directorate Flexible Resource pool for staff between roles, without a headcount.
The Home Office, the Treasury, and the Department for Business and Trade each declined a figure with the same line: the exact number changes day to day.
It may be the only thing in Whitehall to have been successfully redeployed.
Wales Paid Chief Executives To Stay Away
The Welsh Government's own pool looks disciplined by comparison. It fell from 45 people to 16 between March 2015 and August 2016, with a longest wait of 16 months. Those figures are a decade old, however, and no all-Wales count has surfaced to replace them.
Blaenau Gwent tells staff to expect 12 weeks at most on its list. The Welsh talent lies elsewhere, in paying people at the top.
Anthony O'Sullivan, chief executive of Caerphilly, was suspended on £137,000 a year in March 2013, after the Wales Audit Office found senior pay rises unlawful. A judge threw out criminal charges in 2015 for lack of evidence.
In March 2016 the suspension was lifted in secret and replaced with "special paid leave", which the public learnt about nine months later from a solicitor's letter.
The council dismissed him for gross misconduct in October 2019, by which time he had drawn almost £900,000. He then received a £110,700 settlement to avoid a tribunal. He has said he has nothing to apologise for.
His two colleagues had by then been lined up for £171,000 and £127,000 after more than four years away on full pay.
Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board went further and did it twice.
When Trevor Purt stepped down in 2015, the board kept paying his £200,000 salary for a year while he was seconded to England. Its chairman called this "probably the best value".
His successor, Gary Doherty, left in February 2020 for a Lancashire trust, and the board expected to pay him at least £188,000 on secondment while also paying his replacement.
The Welsh Government's contribution was to call this an "operational matter."
Lower down, the same board kept at least eight staff suspended on full pay for five years after the Tawel Fan ward closed in 2013. No individual had been found responsible, and nothing suggested they were at fault.
The bill may have topped £1m, or £2m with agency cover. They were allowed to work elsewhere with permission while drawing their wages.
Across Wales, Freedom of Information requests by the Welsh Conservatives found 16 of 22 councils paid £7.1m to 764 suspended staff over three years, at an average of 32 weeks each.
A later round found at least 236 NHS Wales staff missed 37,000 working days to suspension between 2018 and 2021. One Cardiff and Vale case lasted five years.
Northern Ireland Lost A Whole Assembly
Northern Ireland has a formal policy for surplus staff. Its boldest experiment in surplus staff, however, was the Assembly. Power-sharing collapsed in January 2017. MLAs drew full salaries until late 2018, and £14.9m had been paid by October 2019 for a legislature which did not legislate.
The UK Government cut pay by 27.5% and defended the rest on the grounds of constituency work.
When Stormont collapsed again in 2022, the same 27.5% cut returned from January 2023, leaving salaries at £37,337.
The Independent Remuneration Board then lifted MLAs' pay 26.8% to £67,200 from April 2026, with stepped cuts of 10% if no Executive forms after an election.
Naomi Long put the case against in one line: "other legislatures in these islands function and deliver".
In 2015, 16 teachers had been suspended for 13 months or longer, in figures showing £4.2m spent on suspended teachers, with almost £1m more on cover.
5,156 Suspended Staff And £46m In 3 Years
Julian Bennett, a Metropolitan Police commander and author of the force's drugs strategy, was suspended in July 2020 after refusing a drugs test. He was dismissed in 2023, won on appeal, and was dismissed again in 2025.
The Met's own assistant commissioner spoke of "the utter waste of public funds". The case is estimated to have cost over £1.5m, and he reportedly leaves with a pension of around £80,000 a year.
Nationally, 750 officers were suspended by August 2025, at £2.6m a month.
In 2022 the figure was 225.
In Scotland, at least 424 public sector workers were suspended with full pay in 2025-26.
NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde alone had logged 15,315 such days since 2022 by last year, at a cost of at least £915,224.
One Scottish Government official spent two years and three months suspended on full pay.
Anthony McNally, a teacher in Bury, was suspended for nine years from 1995 over an allegation on which the police, the NSPCC, and his school's governors all cleared him. Bury's bill reached £1m, and the teacher lost a career.
A system which pays everyone in full has no reason to hurry for anyone.
The broadest count, from ITV in 2016, found 5,156 suspended staff and £46m in three years across councils, NHS trusts, and police forces in England and Wales.
Nobody publishes a current figure.
Hidden Union Work On The Public Payroll
Some public employees are paid in full to work for somebody else. Their employer knows this, and calls it "facility time." In October 2012, the Cabinet Office declared civil servants must spend at least half their hours on their actual jobs.
The rule survives. Other limits do not.
Another new useless "framework" published this spring scrapped the hard cap of 0.1% of the paybill, turning it into a suggestion, and encouraged departments to consider paid time off for union conferences.
The latest figures show £13.75m spent across 38 civil service organisations in 2024-25.
The Scottish Prison Service led the table at 0.69% of its paybill, or £1.88m, with 26 people spending all of their paid time on union work. HMRC, with 776 representatives, reported one such person.
The Government calls "facility time" a long-standing legal right.
It has also decided the public need no longer see the numbers: the Employment Rights Act 2025 repeals the publication requirement, for a claimed saving of £300,000 a year.
Paid To Leave, Hired To Return
England's preferred method runs in the opposite direction, and it fails in its own way. The state pays people to go and then hires them back. You couldn't make this up, nor could you ever run a private business in such a spectacularly foolish and dysfunctional way.
The Treasury's own consultation records 19,000 NHS redundancies under the coalition's reorganisation, with 17% rehired, most within a year.
Northern Ireland's Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute apparently spent £4.8m on a voluntary exit scheme and then paid £126,000 in a single year to bring 11 leavers back through agencies.
Parliament responded with section 154 of the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015, which lets the Treasury make regulations to recover exit payments from those who return.
Amendments made in 2016 gave Scottish Ministers a matching role. Regulations were promised for April 2016.
The Treasury's page, last updated in July 2018, still reads: "We are continuing to consider responses to this consultation."
The separate £95,000 cap on exit payments took over five years to arrive and was scrapped within months.
The Civil Service recovers money on a return within six months. The NHS England redundancy scheme now applies a six-month clawback to all staff, and 12 months to the most senior, and the unions refused to endorse it.
Scotland's cost recurs every year, and the minister responsible could not put a figure on it.
Consolidation Means More Ghost Salaries
All of this happened during ordinary administration. Scotland is about to attempt something else. That sentence alone should cause any Scotsman to shudder. The Programme for Government will cut territorial health boards from 14 to two.
Swinney also wants fewer councils and substantially fewer public bodies, from a total above 130 (good). McKee concedes there will be less need for director-level roles.
The Government faces a budget gap of almost £5bn.
Its target is to shrink the workforce, yet the devolved public sector employed 553,600 people in June, 6,060 more than a year before.
On 30th September, Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth told MSPs the plans to shrink the public sector were "off course".
Every merged board means fewer directors, fewer finance teams, and fewer human resources departments.
Every abolished post held by someone who refuses to leave lands in the same pool which has already held one person for 17 years.
Reform on these terms abolishes the job and keeps the salary, and no minister has said where the saving then appears.
Fixing This Persistent Disaster
None of this needs a royal commission, and most of it needs only a change of policy. Any small businessman could take these people by the scruff of the neck and explain what needs to happen. Voters need to enforce it.
Set a hard time limit on redeployment
Clackmannanshire shows six months works. Twelve should be the most any public body allows, with Boyter's two years as the outer limit for exceptional cases. At the end, the employee accepts a suitable post or takes the severance terms on offer. Scottish ministers should say so openly and retire the phrase "no compulsory redundancy", which no longer describes their own position.
Make refusal count
An unreasonable refusal of suitable work should end pay protection, as it ends redundancy rights elsewhere.
Publish one return
Every public body in all four administrations should report each year, on one definition, the number of staff without substantive posts, how long each has waited, what duties they hold, and what they cost. The auditors general should check it. Craig Hoy has asked Scotland's Auditor General to investigate, and Audit Wales and the Northern Ireland Audit Office should run the same exercise.
Put a clock on suspension
Any suspension beyond six months should require sign-off by a named senior officer, with quarterly public reporting of numbers, length, and cost.
Make the clawback regulations
The power has sat in statute for over a decade. The Treasury should finish considering its consultation, and Scottish Ministers should use their own share of the power.
Restore the receipts on facility time
Parliament should reinstate publication and the hard cap, and devolved ministers should adopt both.
Nobody has yet said what the NHS Highland employee has been doing since the post disappeared.
Perhaps it was useful work.
A government which cannot say, after 17 years, has no business promising to reform anything larger than a filing cabinet.